0
0
[ad_1]
De Bruyne, Henderson and ‘soft’ penalties – www.espn.com – SOCCER
Video assistant referee causes controversy every week in the Premier League, but how are decisions made, and are they correct?
After each weekend we take a look at the major incidents, to examine and explain the process both in terms of VAR protocol and the Laws of the Game.
– How VAR decisions affected every Prem club in 2022-23
– VAR’s wildest moments: Alisson’s two red cards in one game
– VAR in the Premier League: Ultimate guide
JUMP TO: Forest 2-2 Brentford | West Ham 1-2 Palace | Chelsea 0-1 Arsenal | Villa 3-1 Man United | Wolves 2-3 Brighton
Possible penalty overturn: Robinson on De Bruyne
What happened: In the 93rd minute, De Bruyne went down under a challenge from Antonee Robinson. Referee Darren England pointed to the penalty spot.
Your Most Trusted Casinos for 2023!
Dream Catcher is Live at Goldman Casino and Offers the Opportunity for some stunning wins up to 40x with Truly Live Presentation! Not Only That, deposit TODAY as a new player and get 100% up to £100 Extra Free to Play + 20 Free Spins on Book of Dead Hit Slot* LIMITED TIME OFFER!!!
*18+ Only New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. Contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests voids all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply.
Wild West Slots at The Fastest Paying Casino in the West!
Goldman Casino has been growing in popularity since 2016, making them one of the best go-to real money online casinos on the market. Goldman Online Casino is powered by over 30 of the best software providers, and its games are provided through an easy-to-use web-based platform.
Get 100% up to £100 Free and 20 Free Spins on Book of Dead when you Deposit!
*18+ Only, New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. Contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests voids all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply
Start Today: Play with Real Money NOW!
More Tried, Tested & Trusted Online Casinos - Available to Players in over 177 Countries!
SlotJar Safe Online Casino
Only the longest established UK casinos, All transactions 100% verified & monitored, fully regulated RNG's, Fastest Paying UK Casinos, Live-Chat and friendliest customer service, 177+ supported countries. 100% satisfaction guarantee.
Lucks Casino is well-trusted and here to stay. LucksCasino.com takes advantage of a full suite of top-tier games, meaning you will always be fully entertained. Check out the deals on the site right now!
- Get 100% up to $€£200 Bonus Today!*
*18+ Only, New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. Contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests voids all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply.
Start Today: Play with Real Money NOW!
Play Securely at LucksCasino.com
SlotJar is your slots pay by phone bill and Online Slots UK Casino jackpots website – It’s not a new casino, it’s been established since 2014, and is one of the most popular slots sites for online and phone payment real money games. Play at SlotJar today and receive a great bonus when you deposit. Play over 2800 different games.
Get 100% Bonus Up to £200 Now!
*18+ Only Full Terms Apply.
Start Today: Play with Real Money NOW!
Fishin' Frenzy Megaways (TM) is a Top UK Slots Game with Huge Rewards! Get the boats to come in and watch your stake multiply x£££ at Lucks Casino!
**18+ Only, New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. Contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests voids all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply.
Start Today: Play with Real Money NOW!
Lucks Casino has been entertaining the gambling masses internationally, since 2015, and continues to offer the finest quality table games with bonuses available throughout the year! Lucks allows you to play on mobile or desktop and cash out quickly in £$€. Players are supported in over 177 countries. Enjoy over 2,500 superb games from the best names in the business!
*18+ Only New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. Contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests voids all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply.
Triple Edge Poker by Betsoft is a thrilling and engaging video poker game that has become increasingly popular among players. The game offers a unique twist on traditional poker and provides players with an immersive gaming experience that is both entertaining and potentially rewarding.
The Advantages of Playing Triple Edge Poker:
- Unique gameplay: Triple Edge Poker introduces a new twist on the classic game of poker, as players are able to play three hands at once instead of just one. This increases the level of excitement and increases the player's chances of winning.
- High-quality graphics: Betsoft is known for its top-notch graphics, and Triple Edge Poker is no exception. The game features realistic and detailed card and table graphics that are sure to immerse players into the game.
- Great payouts: Triple Edge Poker offers players the opportunity to win big, with payouts that are often higher than traditional video poker games.
- Convenient and accessible: Triple Edge Poker can be played on desktop and mobile devices, making it convenient for players to access and play the game from wherever they are.
- Exciting bonus features: Triple Edge Poker features several exciting bonus features, including the chance to win extra payouts and participate in bonus rounds.
- Overall, Triple Edge Poker by Betsoft is a great choice for players who are looking for a unique and thrilling video poker experience. The game's combination of exciting gameplay, high-quality graphics, and great payouts make it a must-try for any fan of video poker.
*18+ Only New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wagers are calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests void all active and pending bonuses. excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply.
Play Online Casino at TopSlotSite.com Get 100% Welcome Bonus up to $€£100 and 20 Free Spins*. Enjoy over 1000 Online Casino & Slots Games NOW! t&c's Apply
100% Satisfaction guaranteed! Yes, Top Slot Site is a Gambling Slot Site Where you can play for Real Money and Get your Winnings with Total Ease. So Relax, Select from over 1000 Superb Games and Enjoy our Live Online Gambling and Casino Betting Mecca.
*18+ Only, New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. Contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests voids all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply.
Established in 2014 and with over 2800 superb games including Slots, Live Casino, Roulette, Blackjack, Instant win and much more TopSlotSite.com is certain to have a game suited to your needs.
Play Online Casino at TopSlotSite.com Get 100% Welcome Bonus up to $€£100 and 20 Free Spins*. Enjoy over 1000 Online Casino & Slots Games NOW! t&c's Apply
100% Satisfaction guaranteed! Yes, Top Slot Site is a Gambling Slot Site Where you can play for Real Money and Get your Winnings with Total Ease. So Relax, Select from over 1000 Superb Games and Enjoy our Live Online Gambling and Casino Betting Mecca.
*18+ Only, New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. Contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests voids all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply.
GoldmanCasino.com is one of the leading online gaming destinations, offering players a wide range of exciting games and endless opportunities to win big. One of the most popular games at the casino is 20p Roulette, a classic casino game that has been enjoyed by players for generations.
This exciting game combines the thrill of chance with the excitement of spinning the wheel, making it the perfect choice for anyone looking for an entertaining and potentially lucrative gaming experience.
Roulette is a simple game to play, with players placing their bets on the numbers or colors they think the ball will land on. The 20p stake means that anyone can enjoy playing this classic game, whether you're a seasoned player or just starting out. With the ease of playing from the comfort of your own home, you can now enjoy the thrill of spinning the wheel without ever having to leave your house.
At GoldmanCasino.com, you'll find a range of different roulette games, including European Roulette and American Roulette. The games are designed to be as realistic as possible, with excellent graphics and sound effects that bring the excitement of the casino to your screen. You'll also find a variety of different betting options, including inside bets and outside bets, so you can choose the type of bet that suits you best.
Another great feature of GoldmanCasino.com is the range of promotions and bonuses available to players. Whether you're a new player or a seasoned pro, you'll find a range of offers that will help you maximize your winnings. For example, the welcome bonus gives new players a chance to double their first deposit, giving them more money to play with and a better chance of hitting a big win.
In addition to the bonuses and promotions, GoldmanCasino.com also offers a range of safe and secure banking options. Whether you prefer to use your credit card, e-wallet, or bank transfer, you'll find a method that suits you. And with 24/7 customer support available, you can be confident that you'll always have help when you need it.
In conclusion, playing 20p Roulette at GoldmanCasino.com is an exciting and potentially lucrative experience. With a wide range of games, bonuses, and promotions, as well as safe and secure banking options, this is the perfect place for anyone looking for an enjoyable and rewarding online gaming experience. So why wait? Head over to Goldman Casino.com today and start spinning the wheel to see if you can win big!
*18+ Only, New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. Contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests voids all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply.
Welcome to LucksCasino.com, the ultimate online casino gaming destination! With over 2800 casino and slots games to choose from, you're sure to find your new favorite game here.
Our casino games include all the classics, such as blackjack, roulette, and baccarat, as well as a variety of exciting variations of these games. We also offer a huge selection of online slots, featuring everything from classic fruit machines to the latest video slots with stunning graphics and bonus features.
At LucksCasino.com, we pride ourselves on offering a safe and secure gaming environment. We use state-of-the-art encryption technology to ensure that your personal and financial information is always protected. Our games are independently tested for fairness by third-party auditors, so you can be sure that you're playing on a level playing field.
We also offer a range of convenient payment options, including credit and debit cards, e-wallets, and bank transfers, so you can choose the method that works best for you. And if you ever need help or support, our friendly and knowledgeable customer service team is available 24/7 to assist you.
As a new player at Lucks Casino.com, you'll be eligible for a range of exciting bonuses and promotions. Our welcome bonus package includes a generous match bonus on your first deposit, as well as free spins on selected slots. We also run regular promotions, such as cashback offers, prize draws, and leader board tournaments, so you can enjoy even more chances to win.
So why wait? Sign up to LucksCasino.com today and start playing your favorite casino and slots games! With over 2800 games to choose from, unbeatable bonuses and promotions, and a safe and secure gaming environment, you're sure to have a fantastic gaming experience.
*18+ Only, New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wagers are calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests void all active and pending bonuses. excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply.
SlotJar is your slots pay by phone bill and Online Slots UK Casino jackpots website – It’s not a new casino, it’s been established since 2014, and is one of the most popular slots sites for online and phone payment real money games. Play at SlotJar today and receive a great bonus when you deposit. Play over 2800 different games.
Get 100% Bonus Up to £200 Now!
*18+ Only Full Terms Apply.
Land the valuable symbols on this amazing slot and experience real JOY and the chance of almost unlimited free spins bonus rounds!
Top Slot Site is packed with over 2800 top slot games for you to enjoy. Get started at this fantastic slots site today!
**18+ Only, New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. Contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests voids all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply.
Lucks Casino is well-trusted and here to stay. LucksCasino.com takes advantage of a full suite of top-tier games, meaning you will always be fully entertained. Check out the deals on the site right now!
- Get 100% up to $€£200 Bonus Today!*
*18+ Only, New Players Only. Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus. Contribution varies per game. selected games only. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Bonus valid 30 days / Free spins valid 7 days from receipt. Max conversion: 3x the bonus amount or from free spins: £20. Withdrawal requests voids all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms Apply.
Start Today: Play with Real Money NOW!
Exciting Theme: The game's theme is based on ancient Egyptian mythology, which creates an exciting and immersive experience for players.
VAR decision: Penalty stands, scored by Erling Haaland for City to win 2-1.
VAR review: Two seasons ago there were lots of “soft” penalties like this. These have mostly been eradicated as referees look for contact with a consequence from the defender, while an exaggerated fall by an attacker is also taken into account — but we still see some given by a referee.
It’s up for debate whether the VAR, Stuart Attwell, would have advised a review for a penalty, due to the way De Bruyne went down theatrically (more on this to come.) But the contact on the Belgian’s ankle by Robinson makes it very unlikely that the VAR would overturn the spot kick if given. The ethos around soft penalties should still be focused on the referee’s decision on the field of play (more on this to come too.)
Kevin De Bruyne is caught by Antonee Robinson inside the area. BBC
The bar is effectively set by the original decision — so similar incidents can result in different outcomes. It’s the major conflict with VAR and subjective decision-making in football.
That said, it doesn’t really feel right that we can still see such soft penalties like this, in game-defining moments, when they are rarely given in other matches.
Red card review: Cancelo on Wilson
What happened: In the 25th minute, Harry Wilson was through on goal when he was bundled over inside the area. Referee England pointed to the penalty spot and sent off Joao Cancelo for denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity (DOGSO.)
VAR decision: Penalty and red card stand.
VAR review: An easy decision for the VAR to confirm. Wilson had control of the ball, was through inside the area and would have got a shot on goal.
Cancelo not only used his upper body to challenge Wilson, he also brought his left leg across the Fulham midfielder and was making no challenge for the ball. It’s that last point which means Cancelo had to be sent off; if the Man City defender had made any attempt at the ball it would only have been a caution.
Harry Wilson was fouled by Joao Cancelo for a penalty and a red card. BBC
This incident does show us how a referee has to act differently as the VAR. If England gave this as a penalty when he was the referee, why didn’t he do so for a similar challenge when acting as the VAR for Tottenham Hotspur vs. Liverpool? Ryan Sessegnon was challenged by Trent Alexander-Arnold in a similar fashion, but referee Andy Madley waved away appeals for a penalty. Surely if England thinks one was a penalty, he should say both are?
But this isn’t the way VAR works. The VAR is acting within the confines of the subjectivity of the referee on the pitch, what Madley describes he saw. With Alexander-Arnold on Sessegnon, it was more a case of the Liverpool defender leaning into Sessegnon rather than there being any shove. If Madley had given a penalty to Spurs, it would have stayed a penalty; it’s in the corridor of subjectivity whereby the VAR will not intervene.
Trent Alexander-Arnold leans into Ryan Sessegnon. BBC
It’s understandable that fans will look at these two incidents and feel that are very similar, featuring the same referee in different roles producing different outcomes. But England is not trying to produce consistency of his own overarching decision-making when judging incidents as the VAR.
VAR overturn: Haaland goal disallowed for offside
What happened: Man City thought they had gone 2-1 up in the 74th minute through Haaland, but there was a review for offside.
VAR decision: Goal disallowed.
VAR review: Although the assistant referee kept his flag down, the VAR lines clearly showed Haaland was in front of the last defender. Remember, the two lines must touch for the attacker to get the benefit of the doubt and the goal to stand.
VAR penalty: Henderson foul on Wissa
What happened: In the 44th minute, Yoane Wissa tried to take the ball past goalkeeper Dean Henderson and went down. Referee Andre Marriner gave a goal kick to Forest.
VAR decision: Penalty, scored by Bryan Mbeumo.
VAR review: This was one of four penalty claims in the game — three for Forest and one for Brentford. Forest boss Steve Cooper was apoplectic that the only VAR overturn went against his team, while Henderson was close to receiving a second yellow card for the way he reacted — both before and after the spot kick was taken.
We’ve talked already about the level of contact, and the reaction of the attacker, and all this comes into play here. It’s also why the decision to give Brentford the penalty goes against PGMOL’s desire not to give soft penalties through VAR intervention. Of course, a subjective argument can be put forward for the decision by the VAR, but that doesn’t mean he should be getting involved.
Dean Henderson makes contact with Yoane Wissa. Justin Setterfield/Getty Images
Did the contact from Henderson cause Wissa to go to ground? The VAR, Lee Mason, decided it was enough to knock him off balance. He may also have given it because Wissa tries to stay on his feet, with no exaggeration in the way he goes to ground. But contact was minimal, and it’s not the first time Mason has become involved in a VAR overturn when it wasn’t necessary.
Mason was correct not to get involved in the other three incidents, but if all four have gone against your team, one resulting in conceding a goal, you can fully understand the frustration from Forest.
In the 13th minute, Mathias Jensen challenged Emmanuel Dennis. Marriner waved play on in this incident, but if anything it could have been a free kick to Brentford as Dennis had caught the midfielder with his studs above the ankle first. Even without the possible foul on Jensen, the fall from the striker was very much exaggerated. There are comparisons to made with the decision given to De Bruyne, as he too produced theatrics to win the penalty — the important factor being the decision was made by the referee and not the VAR.
Mathias Jensen is caught by Emmanuel Dennis before the secondary contact on the attacker. BBC
Step forward to the 30th minute, when Josh Dasilva placed an arm on Ryan Yates, but the Forest midfielder went down easily. It’s doubtful that the force used caused Yates to go to ground in the way he did, and for this reason the VAR is unlikely to get involved, whichever way the referee has chosen to go.
Was Josh Dasilva’s arm on Ryan Yates enough for a penalty? BBC
The final penalty claim for Forest came in the 70th minute, Morgan Gibbs-White going down under a challenge from Ben Mee; the Forest player appears to bring his right foot across to initiate the contact with the defender. Again, no VAR intervention is understandable.
Morgan Gibbs-White appears to place his right leg into the path of Ben Mee’s foot. BBC
The best outcome would have been no penalties in any of these four situations.
Possible offside: Yates on Jorgensen own goal
What happened: Mathias Jorgensen put through his own goal six minutes into stoppage time but there was a check for offside against Yates.
VAR decision: Goal stands.
VAR review: The VAR had two things to take into account — was Yates in the line of vision of the defender on the line, Mee, or did Yates challenge for the ball? He cannot be offside just by his position.
Mee had a view of the ball and was able to make an attempted clearance. When the ball looped back toward goal off Jorgensen, Yates could still have been given offside as Mee’s clearance doesn’t reset the phase, but the Forest player did not directly challenge the Brentford defender.
Ryan Yates was in an offside position but did not interfere with play. BBC
VAR overturn: Penalty cancelled for Guehi challenge on Antonio
What happened: West Ham were awarded a penalty in the 81st minute when Michail Antonio went down under a challenge from Marc Guehi.
VAR decision: Penalty cancelled.
VAR review: Referee Paul Tierney felt that Antonio had been pulled back by Guehi, but it was clear from the replays there was no contact of any note.
There’s a strong case for Antonio to be booked for simulation for the way he goes to ground, and that option is open to Tierney at the monitor. But Chelsea’s Callum Hudson-Odoi is the only player to be booked on a penalty overturn since VAR came into the Premier League.
Michail Antonio goes to ground after going past Marc Guehi. Rob Newell – CameraSport via Getty Images
Possible penalty: Handball by Cucurella
What happened: In the 80th minute the ball struck the arm of Marc Cucurella, referee Michael Oliver allowed play to continue.
VAR decision: No penalty.
VAR review: The handball was on the blind side of referee OIiver, so it’s understandable he may not have seen it. The decision for the VAR, Jarred Gillett, is about proof that the handball happened inside the area and not outside.
The rear view created enough doubt that the handball took place outside, which means the VAR cannot get involved. That Cucurella’s feet were inside the area is irrelevant, only where the ball is when it touches the arm matters.
Possible red card: Martinez challenge on Bailey
What happened: In the 64th minute, Lisandro Martinez was trying to guard the ball out for a goal kick when he appeared to throw an elbow into Leon Bailey.
VAR decision: No red card.
VAR review: There’s no doubt that Martinez took a huge risk in the way he challenged Bailey, who was furious with the defender’s actions after the game. But there isn’t enough in this for the VAR to get involved and review it for a red card. It looks far worse in slow motion, and in full speed there’s very little in it.
Leon Bailey of Aston Villa battles for possession with Lisandro Martinez. James Gill/Getty Images
VAR overturn: Penalty for handball against Dunk
What happened: In the 35th minute, Daniel Podence tried to hook the ball across the area and appealed for handball against Lewis Dunk. Referee Graham Scott waved play on.
VAR decision: Penalty, scored by Ruben Neves.
VAR review: The only question for the VAR was whether the ball touched Dunk’s arm, as it’s high in an unnatural position. This comes down to the burden of proof and the VAR, John Brooks, decided there was the evidence that the ball touched the arm.
Lewis Dunk raises his arm as Daniel Podence plays the ball in the box. BBC
Red card review: Semedo sent off
What happened: Wolves defender Nelson Semedo was sent off in first-half injury time for DOGSO when fouling Kaoru Mitoma.
VAR decision: Red card stands.
VAR review: This could be seen by some as a borderline call for a red card, because Mitoma is in a wide area. However, the Brighton forward got an important touch to take the ball into the box toward goal, creating the goal-scoring chance with the goalkeeper inside his six-yard box and unable to get to the ball first. For that reason it wouldn’t be considered a wrong decision to show the red card.
Kaoru Mitoma had played the ball toward goal to create an obvious goal-scoring opportuniuty. BBC
Information provided by the Premier League and PGMOL was used in this story.
[ad_2]
#Bruyne #Henderson #soft #penalties
